Briscoe, E. J., A. Copestake, and A. Lascarides, [1995] Blocking, in St. Dizier, P. and Viegas, E. Computational Lexical Semantics, pp273--302, Cambridge University Press.
A major motivation for the introduction of default inheritance mechanisms into theories of lexical organisation has been to account for the prevalence of the family of phenomena variously described as blocking (Aronoff, 1976:43), the elsewhere condition (Kiparsky, 1973), or preemption by synonymy (Clark and Clark, 1979:798). In Copestake and Briscoe (1991) we argued that productive processes of sense extension also undergo the same process, suggesting that an integrated account of lexical semantic and morphological processes must allow for blocking. In this paper, we review extant accounts which follow from theories of lexical organisation based on default inheritance, such as Paradigmatic Morphology (Calder, 1989), {\sc datr} (Evans \& Gazdar, 1989), ELU (Russell et al., 1991, in press), Word Grammar (Hudson, 1990; Fraser and Hudson, 1992), or the LKB (Copestake 1992; this volume; Copestake et al., in press). We argue that these theories fail to capture the full complexity of even the simplest cases of blocking and sketch a more adequate framework, based on a nonmonotonic logic that incorporates more powerful mechanisms for resolving conflict among defeasible knowledge resources (Commonsense Entailment, Asher and Morreau, 1991). Finally, we explore the similarities and differences between various phenomena which have been intuitively felt to be cases of blocking within this formal framework, and discuss the manner in which such processes might interact with more general interpretative strategies during language comprehension. Our presentation is necessarily brief and rather informal; we are primarily concerned to point out the potential advantages using a more expressive default logic for remedying some of the inadequacies of current theories of lexical description.
@incollection{briscoe:etal:1995,
author = {Ted Briscoe and Ann Copestake and Alex Lascarides},
year = {1995},
title = {Blocking},
editor = {P.\ St Dizier and E.\ Viegas},
booktitle = {Computational Lexical Semantics},
pages = {273--302},
publisher = {Cambridge University Press}
}